La Ville Invisible. [Text]

by Katja Stuke with Oliver Sieber

Böhm Kobayashi ·

In this chapter of Cartographie Dynamique, we look at the influence and long-term impact of major events such as the Olympic Games on the structure of cities. We are interested in the sometimes radical changes that follow these mass events, as well as in infrastructure planning and its social consequences. We do not see ourselves as activists for any particular cause. In our photographic and artistic work, however, we take up the (urban) landscape around us and the society we live in. We understand the activist question “Who owns the city?” as an invitation to look closely. Our interest in urban peripheries, like our choice of the cities we work in, stems from biographical experience and visual curiosity. For more than 20 years we have regularly spent time in Paris as well as in Osaka and Tokyo. Over this period, fundamental changes have become apparent. It is in suburbs and in seemingly uninteresting places that we find the subjects that also interest us photographically.

Walking

As a rule, we make the cities we live and work in our own by walking. Yoko Tawada's line “Walking is like thinking without words” has stayed with us for a very long time. For us, walking is a process of seeing, recognising and sensing changes over long periods of time. Different projects revolve around very different questions: identity and geography in “Japanese Lesson”; in “Monde de Demain” we explore the relationship between periphery and centre with regard to subculture. In “Ville Lumière” we observe the effect of protests on the city beyond the protest routes. The “Walk the Walk” through Chongqing follows a route in Düsseldorf. Our “Walks” are not aimless, yet we follow the attitude of the Situationists in their dérives: walking for hours through the urban environment is the basis for understanding and inspiration.

SOCIAL Landscape or NEW NEW TOPOGRAPHICS

The work Japanese Lesson was created in 2017. What interested us most were the social and societal questions we had noticed while exploring various districts of Tokyo and Osaka. We concentrated above all on the boundaries between neighbourhoods, which were sometimes social boundaries as well. Later, our attention was drawn to Masao Adachi's “Landscape Theory” and his view of the (urban) landscape. He asks how the city, and specifically its architecture and its image, affects society, but also each and every one of us. Who makes decisions about interventions and changes? Who decides how cities look and work? And how do we feel this in ourselves? These questions play a central role in many of our series. Alongside the street photographs of the Walks (often in central perspective), our series may also include portraits or scans of objects. Our research on each subject also results in websites, gestures, reference libraries or glossaries, and thus becomes part of the artwork.

EXPO, OLYMPIC GAMES AND CONSTRUCTION SITES

Our interest in these major events took concrete shape in 2018, when it was confirmed that a World Expo, the EXPO, would once again take place in Osaka in 2025, and precisely in Konohana, the district of Osaka where we regularly live and work. Osaka had hosted a World Expo once before: the Osaka EXPO '70 is still regarded as groundbreaking today. At an event in the EXPO Park in Osaka in 2006, we had met the Japanese artist Yanobe Kenji, whose questions about the “ruins of the future” have stayed with us ever since.

Other districts then came into our field of view. Shin Sekai (New World) was first planned in 1903 for a national industrial exhibition and developed in 1912 into the Luna amusement park. During the preparations for EXPO 70, the construction workers were housed in accommodation built especially for the purpose, which is still rented out today as cheap apartments. In 2006, Shin Sekai was one of the poorest and “darkest” districts of Osaka. It has since been gentrified into a rather overcrowded tourist hotspot.

Senri New Town was built at the same time as EXPO 70: a dormitory town made up of apartment blocks of various sizes, danchis (social housing estates) and smaller bungalows. There is also a monorail and a nuclear power plant that supplied EXPO 70 with electricity.

This interest in planned cities also took us to Songdo in South Korea, a Smart City built between 2003 and around 2012. There, the lack of empty spaces, in-between spaces and spaces for unplanned use could be felt directly. We made the same observation in some of the Paris suburbs. Old industrial buildings, wasteland and abandoned spaces that can be appropriated and transformed have no place in the planning of new cities. As a result, there is no room for potential that emerges slowly and organically and develops over a long period of time.

Construction of the venues for the Tokyo Olympic Games had already begun in 2017. That same year, Paris was announced as host city of the 2024 Olympic Games. In Paris, the construction of entirely new metro lines and the overhaul of the infrastructure, especially beyond the Boulevard Périphérique, were also pushed forward. For a long time, the Paris metro was a political tool for controlling who could reach the city centre quickly. Now there is the Grand Paris Express, which allows people in the suburbs to get into the city quickly, but also directly to other suburbs. The last section is due to be completed in 2030. The new urban changes that follow will certainly be worth watching.

In Tokyo we were particularly interested in Miyashita Park: a former public park with a skatepark, where many homeless people also lived in shelters neatly built from blue tarpaulin and cardboard. The skatepark is now on the roof of a shopping mall, and skaters who want to use the small ramps also have to buy a ticket. With Yumeshima in Osaka, and Ariake and Harumi in Tokyo, previously undeveloped artificial islands built on landfill were used for the EXPO, several Olympic events and the newly built Olympic Village.

During the 2024 Olympic Games in Paris, we took some final photographs and experienced the immediate impact of the event as well as its short-term restrictions. Two further issues caught our attention: on the occasion of the Olympic Games, both Paris and Tokyo passed changes to the law that allow more extensive surveillance and the linking of facial recognition with movement profiles.

Construction-site structures take up a large part of the work La Ville Invisible. Buildings with the most varied functions are going up on previously undeveloped land and wasteland as well as on former industrial sites. But new complexes are also being built in the midst of existing structures and have to fit into their surroundings. Construction sites interest us because it is on construction sites that transformations become visible. In their incompleteness, a utopia still seems possible and the outcome still open, despite the perfect three-dimensional renderings of the projects on the site hoardings. The construction site is thus a metaphor for possibility. Finished projects, on the other hand, do not interest us. However, an exhibition took us to Seoul in 2023. The Olympic Games were held there too, in 1988. To build the village, residents had to leave their homes under the military government of the time and were resettled. Many of them ended up in Guryong Village, a shantytown where at times up to 1,000 people lived. Today the roughly 600 people who live there are fighting another eviction. Guryong Village lies in the sought-after Gangnam district and has long been targeted by urban development plans. Construction sites for new large-scale projects are already, quite literally, on the other side of the street.

For a final chapter of La Ville Invisible, we selected photographs of Sarajevo from our archive. In 2014 we had photographed there for the project You and Me; among other things, images were also taken at several former venues of the 1984 Winter Olympics. During the Bosnian War in the 1990s, they became battlegrounds.

THE PHOTOGRAPHIC STATES OF MATTER

They thus regard not only the conception and production of photographs, but also the editing and distribution of images, as an important part of the most diverse fields of application of photography. Which motifs are understood and interpreted, and in what context? How does the design environment influence a photographic motif, what happens to images in different sequences, what defines the quality and meaning of images? What does the “notion of originality” mean in the context of the many states of photography (as a print, framed picture, book illustration, advertising or magazine image, slide, black-and-white photocopy or digital file)? (Dr Sabine Maria Schmidt)

La Ville Invisible contains 148 photographs from various European and Asian cities. We took them over the course of seven years, returning again and again to particular places. We are interested in both the similarities and the differences between the cities, and in how each place changes over time. Our understanding of photography here is perhaps similar to that of martial arts: with the camera we respond to what is there, to what acts upon us. The city looks at us, and with photography we look back.

Our joint work began in 1999 with photo zines. The first inkjet printers and suitable paper allowed us to conceive and produce magazines/zines in very small editions. We see ourselves on the one hand in the do-it-yourself tradition of punk and hip-hop zines, and on the other in that of the various practices of artists' books, or of Lucy Lippard's idea of “exhibiting in publications”.

As a rule, a work first takes shape as a book. While we work on the book, certain aspects of the work become clearer, decisions are made, and the photographs are structured and ordered.

For La Ville Invisible we use our black-and-white photocopier almost as a darkroom and an artistic tool for developing our photographs: the copier gives the images their particular screen. Under Schwarzes Licht we group together the joint projects that deal with the form of photographic images. Fax from the Library is about the reproduction of photographic images and the relationship between a photograph and its original. This is also visible in the appearance of our photographs. The process of reproduction also plays an essential role in the choice of each individual motif. Beyond the content, the images always reveal a stance towards the photographic, the medium and its reception.

Form follows Content

The work was exhibited under the title Ruinen der Zukunft at the Fondation de l'Allemagne / Cité Universitaire in Paris, even before the book, already conceived, was finished. We installed a large selection of motifs from the work, in a site-specific way, in the large windows of the foyer. Thanks to the translucent, newsprint-like paper, the photographs could be viewed as if in a light box. Our photographic works develop over long periods, often in series that we pursue over several years. Decisions about the conception of exhibitions and installations, by contrast, are made and carried out in a concentrated and swift way. For us, photographic images are not fixed; in keeping with the subject, they can be rethought and recombined again and again: in other formats, in other juxtapositions, in different spatial settings.

A few final motifs were added while the exhibition in Paris was running. The book La Ville Invisible came out a few weeks later. Individual motifs from the book's various chapters also exist as portfolios of about nine to twelve motifs each.

Featured editions

Illustration for La Ville Invisible. [Text]